JournalMANI DASTGERDI0%
Journal

A galaxy of noodles: the AI idea that was dropped, not patched

What a failed concept in a fully AI-produced pitch film shows about where human judgment has to sit.

MDMani DastgerdiCreative Director7 October 2026

A pitch film for European wholesale buyers, produced entirely with AI. One concept came out wrong. Here is why it was dropped, and what replaced it.

A galaxy of noodles: the AI idea that was dropped, not patched
The brief

Samyang needed to enter the EU wholesale market. There was no footage, no lifestyle material and no narrative. Only charts, data and product specs. The job: a pitch film for category managers at major European retail chains, made entirely with AI video generation and motion graphics. No live shoot.

The first idea

In ideation the idea went toward a galaxy of flavors rising from every noodle cup. It sounded big. The AI kept pulling it further toward abstraction.

What came out

In execution the images came out like bloody brains, almost zombie-like. Far from the brand's identity, which is crazy fun.

Dropped, not patched

The idea was wrong, so it was dropped, not patched. A better prompt, another model or a new grade would only have polished the wrong idea. The rule that came out of it: when the failure is in the idea, no tool can fix it. Only a person can say so.

What replaced it

A five-act, two-minute film for European buyers, built on market data, a new face called Peppo and the XL format.

The fun came back, now with a business argument.

Where the human sat

Every visual was created from scratch with AI-generated cinematics and motion design. The decisions that mattered were not generated: killing the galaxy, building the film on market data, and ending on an invitation to partner instead of a sales line.

Full case with the rejected frames: manidastgerdi.com/portfolio/buldak-xl

Written by Mani Dastgerdi, Creative Director

← All notes
Journal

Latest notes

All notes
7 Oct 2026A galaxy of noodles: the AI idea that was dropped, not patched19 May 2026The authenticity obsession in UGC is making your ads worse.18 Nov 2025How to Explain Your SaaS Product Clearly in the First 10 Seconds